i suppose i might almost class my devotion to english reviews among my literary passions, but it was of very short lease, not beyond a year or two at the most. in the midst of it i made my first and only essay aside from the lines of literature, or rather wholly apart from it. after some talk with my father it was decided, mainly by myself, i suspect, that i should leave the printing-office and study law; and it was arranged with the united states senator who lived in our village, and who was at home from washington for the summer, that i was to come into his office. the senator was by no means to undertake my instruction himself; his nephew, who had just begun to read law, was to be my fellow-student, and we were to keep each other up to the work, and to recite to each other, until we thought we had enough law to go before a board of attorneys and test our fitness for admission to the bar.

this was the custom in that day and place, as i suppose it is still in most parts of the country. we were to be fitted for practice in the courts, not only by our reading, but by a season of pettifogging before justices of the peace, which i looked forward to with no small shrinking of my shy spirit; but what really troubled me most, and was always the grain of sand between my teeth, was blackstone's confession of his own original preference for literature, and his perception that the law was "a jealous mistress," who would suffer no rival in his affections. i agreed with him that i could not go through life with a divided interest; i must give up literature or i must give up law. i not only consented to this logically, but i realized it in my attempt to carry on the reading i had loved, and to keep at the efforts i was always making to write something in verse or prose, at night, after studying law all day. the strain was great enough when i had merely the work in the printing-office; but now i came home from my blackstone mentally fagged, and i could not take up the authors whom at the bottom of my heart i loved so much better. i tried it a month, but almost from the fatal day when i found that confession of blackstone's, my whole being turned from the "jealous mistress" to the high minded muses: i had not only to go back to literature, but i had also to go back to the printing-office. i did not regret it, but i had made my change of front in the public eye, and i felt that it put me at a certain disadvantage with my fellow- citizens; as for the senator, whose office i had forsaken, i met him now and then in the street, without trying to detain him, and once when he came to the printing-office for his paper we encountered at a point where we could not help speaking. he looked me over in my general effect of base mechanical, and asked me if i had given up the law; i had only to answer him i had, and our conference ended. it was a terrible moment for me, because i knew that in his opinion i had chosen a path in life, which if it did not lead to the poor house was at least no way to the white house. i suppose now that he thought i had merely gone back to my trade, and so for the time i had; but i have no reason to suppose that he judged my case narrow-mindedly, and i ought to have had the courage to have the affair out with him, and tell him just why i had left the law; we had sometimes talked the english reviews over, for he read them as well as i, and it ought not to have been impossible for me to be frank with him; but as yet i could not trust any one with my secret hope of some day living for literature, although i had already lived for nothing else. i preferred the disadvantage which i must be at in his eyes, and in the eyes of most of my fellow-citizens; i believe i had the applause of the organ-builder, who thought the law no calling for me.

in that village there was a social equality which, if not absolute, was as nearly so as can ever be in a competitive civilization; and i could have suffered no slight in the general esteem for giving up a profession and going back to a trade; if i was despised at all it was because i had thrown away the chance of material advancement; i dare say some people thought i was a fool to do that. no one, indeed, could have imagined the rapture it was to do it, or what a load rolled from my shoulders when i dropped the law from them. perhaps sinbad or christian could have conceived of my ecstatic relief; yet so far as the popular vision reached i was not returning to literature, but to the printing business, and i myself felt the difference. my reading had given me criterions different from those of the simple life of our village, and i did not flatter myself that my calling would have been thought one of great social dignity in the world where i hoped some day to make my living. my convictions were all democratic, but at heart i am afraid i was a snob, and was unworthy of the honest work which i ought to have felt it an honor to do; this, whatever we falsely pretend to the contrary, is the frame of every one who aspires beyond the work of his hands. i do not know how it had become mine, except through my reading, and i think it was through the devotion i then had for a certain author that i came to a knowledge not of good and evil so much as of common and superfine.