what had become of the boats? i was a commodore without a squadron, and i felt so cheap that i would have sold out my commission for sixpence, and thrown myself in. the boats had been carefully secured, under my own direction, in the little inlet, and they could not have drifted away, i looked at bob hale, and bob hale looked at me; but neither of us could explain the disappearance of the fleet.

"an enemy hath done this," i began, in scripture phrase.

"of course it couldn't have been done by a friend," added tom rush. "it's lucky we have a good stock of provisions on hand."

"but the stock won't last forever," suggested bob.[189]

"we are not going to be starved out in a week, or a year, for that matter," i interposed. "we are not to be broken up by any such accident as this."

"the commodore is spunky," laughed bob, who was always good-natured, whatever happened.

"i am not to be put down by any such expedient as this taking away the boats. when i want to visit the main shore, i shall do so, boat or no boat," i replied; for i already saw how i could counteract the misfortune of the loss of our squadron.

"parasyte has snuffed us out, i suppose, and sent a party up here in the night to take the boats," continued bob hale. "he means to starve us out."

"he will discover his mistake. but let us take a look round the island; perhaps we may find out what has become of the boats;" and i led the way to the nearest point, at which a sentinel had been stationed.

the student on watch there knew nothing of the absence of the boats. there had been no alarm given at the guard tent. we walked around the island without obtaining any information of the lost[190] squadron. we reported the mishap to vallington, who was both surprised and indignant.

the occupants of the guard tent were all turned out, and those who had been on watch during the night were examined; but none of them knew anything about the boats. they had not heard any noise during the night, or seen anything on the lake. the general then mustered the company, and after stating what had occurred, called for any information; but no one had any to give.

"where is bill poodles?" suddenly demanded bob hale, as he glanced around among the students.

"he is not here," replied tom rush, after he had scrutinized all the faces.

"and dick pearl?"

"not here."

"is any of the party that came off that night present?" demanded the general.

"no," answered several, after each fellow had looked his neighbor full in the face.

"that's what's the matter!" exclaimed bob hale. "bill poodles and the rest of them have run away with the boats; and in my opinion that's what they joined us for."[191]

a further examination convinced all present that this was the fact. it looked as though mr. parasyte had sent off the ten boys who joined us on the first night, to rob us of the boats. we remembered the dismay with which pearl and poodles had listened to the announcement of our intended removal from cleaver island, and were fully confirmed in our view of the traitors' purpose.

we found that the conspirators had all occupied the same tent, and one of the fellows who slept with them now remembered that he had half waked up, and heard dick pearl talking in a low tone to some one. vallington called up the sentinels again, and spoke pretty sharply to them of their neglect of duty.

"it would have been impossible for them to carry off the boats if you had been awake; and now you have got us into a pretty scrape. we shall have to back out, and march back to the institute like whipped puppies," said he, with becoming indignation.

but the sentinels protested that they had kept awake all the time.[192]

"tell that to a dead mule, and he would kick your brains out," replied the general. "who stood at the south station?"

"i did from ten till twelve," answered joe slivers; "and i am sure no boat went out of the cove during that time."

"and who from twelve till two?" continued the general.

no one answered.

"who was it—don't you know?" demanded vallington, sternly.

"i know," replied ben lyons. "it was carl dorner, for i had the north station at the same time."

"carl dorner!" exclaimed bob hale. "he was one of the poodles party."

"that accounts for it," added vallington. "who had the east station from twelve till two?"

"mat murray," replied slivers.

"he's another of the poodles tribe," added bob. "it's as clear as mud now. we put traitors on guard, and we are sold out."

"ben lyons, you had the north station from twelve till two," continued the general.[193]

"i did; but i was nearly half a mile from the cove," replied the sentinel.

"and carl dorner and mat murray had the east and south stations at the same time."

"they did."

"who called the fellows that were to relieve you?"

"i did," answered lyons.

"didn't you miss dorner and murray?"

"i didn't notice them; but i did see the three fellows who went on guard at two o'clock. they started for their stations, and i turned in, without thinking anything about dorner and murray."

it further appeared that the two traitors had used some "shuffling" to obtain the east and south stations. it was evident now that the conspirators had executed their plan shortly after midnight, while their associates were on guard at the two posts where their operations could be seen or heard. the south station was on a point of land which commanded a full view of the cove where the boats lay. from the east station the lake in the direction of parkville and cannondale could be seen. from the north[194] station, which was considerably farther west than either of the other posts, nothing could be seen on the south side of the island.

if the conspirators had gone to the eastward with the boats, they could easily have kept out of sight of the sentinel at the north station—the only true one on duty when the mischief was done—by hugging the main south shore of the lake. if they had gone to the westward, or farther away from parkville,—which was not likely,—they could not have been seen by ben lyons till they had gone at least a mile.

in the mud at the bottom of the cove we found a pole sticking up, which the traitors had probably used in pushing the scow out into the lake. this showed us in what manner they had gone to work; but i was satisfied that they had not attempted to tow the scow any distance; it would not have been possible for them to do so. it was comparatively easy to move her with setting-poles, but they could have done nothing with the unwieldy craft in the deep water. i therefore concluded that they had merely pushed her out into the[195] lake, and then turned her adrift. it was probable that she had been driven ashore by the north-west wind somewhere in the vicinity of cannondale.

what the conspirators had done with the splash was not so clear to me, for not one of them knew anything about the management of a sail-boat. she had a pair of oars on board, and it was probable they had rowed her, as they had the other boats. all the sentinels agreed in their statements that the wind had blown pretty fresh in the night, and i was not quite willing to believe that the ten faithless ones had pulled the four boats the whole distance to parkville, which was nine miles, in the heavy sea that must have been caused by a brisk north-west wind. they were not boatmen enough to undertake such a job, or to carry it through if they did attempt it.

cannondale lay to the south-east of pine island, and with the prevailing wind of the night, it was an easy matter to accomplish the two miles which lay between them. after a great deal of thinking, reasoning, and studying, i came to the conclusion[196] that the splash, and perhaps two or three of the four row-boats,—for the conspirators had added one to our original number,—were not farther off than cannondale. the wind was still fresh from the north-west, and the traitors would hardly care to pull even a single boat eight miles. the steamer, on her way to parkville, would touch at cannondale about one o'clock, and i surmised that the deserters would return in her.

i made up my mind, in view of these facts and suppositions, that it would be advisable for some of our party to visit cannondale before one o'clock. pine island had sometimes been used as a picnic ground, and the people had been conveyed thither in a steamer. near the south station, in the deepest water, there was a rude pier of logs built out, for the convenience of landing the parties. this loose structure suggested to me the means of reaching the main shore; and, without waiting for breakfast, i "piped" away my boatmen, and proceeded to build a raft.

placing three large logs in the water, we lashed them together, and covered them with short pieces[197] of board, from the ruins of an old cook-house on the island. the job was finished when breakfast was ready, about seven o'clock, including a mast and sail, the latter made of the curtain of a tent. the preparations i had been making had a wonderful effect in warming up the spirits of the boys, considerably depressed by the prospective calamities which were supposed to lie in the wake of the loss of our boats; and at least three quarters of them applied to me for permission to join my expedition to the main shore. i determined, however, to take but four with me, among whom were bob hale and tom rush.

as soon as we had eaten a hearty breakfast, we embarked, and hoisted the sail on our clumsy craft. when she had passed out of the cove, she took the breeze, and went off at a very satisfactory pace towards cannondale, plunging and rolling in the heavy sea like a ship in a gale. with us as navigators, "the die was cast," for it would be impossible to return to the island unless the wind changed, for the raft would only go before it.

the craft dived down and jumped up, and every[198] wave swept completely over it; but we had taken off our shoes and stockings, and rolled up our trousers' legs, so that we suffered no inconvenience. the fresh breeze carried us over in about half an hour, and the raft was thrown high and dry on the beach, a quarter of a mile below the town.